Dark roast coffee doesn’t have to taste burnt. That’s the thing most people get wrong. They’ve been drinking over-roasted commodity coffee and assume that’s what dark roast is supposed to taste like.
I spent two months working through over 20 bags of dark roast beans to find the ones that actually taste good—bold and rich without that acrid, ashy flavor. Here’s what I found.
What Makes a Good Dark Roast
Dark roasting brings oils to the surface of the bean and caramelizes the sugars. Done right, you get chocolate, caramel, and smoky sweetness. Done wrong, you get charcoal.
The key factors:
- Bean quality: Dark roasting hides flaws, which is why cheap coffee is often dark roasted. Good roasters use quality beans anyway.
- Roast timing: There’s a narrow window between fully developed and burnt. Skilled roasters hit it consistently.
- Freshness: Dark roast beans go stale faster because the oils are exposed. Buy from roasters with clear roast dates.
Best Overall: Peet’s Coffee Major Dickason’s Blend
Major Dickason’s has been Peet’s flagship for decades, and it deserves the reputation. This is what dark roast should taste like.
The flavor profile hits chocolate, smoke, and a hint of berry sweetness. It’s bold without being bitter, complex without being fussy. Works beautifully in any brew method—drip, French press, espresso, pour-over.
Peet’s roasts frequently and ships fresh. The bags have roast dates, and mine usually arrive within 2-3 weeks of roasting.
Tasting notes: Dark chocolate, smoke, dried fruit
Best for: People who want a versatile, reliable dark roast
Best for Espresso: Lavazza Super Crema
This Italian blend is technically medium-dark, but it drinks like a proper dark roast and makes exceptional espresso.
The flavor is smooth with notes of honey, almonds, and brown sugar. Lower acidity than most dark roasts, which makes it forgiving in espresso—even slightly over-extracted shots taste good.
Fair warning: this is an oily bean. Your grinder will need more frequent cleaning. Worth it for the results.
Tasting notes: Honey, almonds, brown sugar
Best for: Home espresso enthusiasts
Best Bold Flavor: Kicking Horse Kick Ass
Canadian roaster Kicking Horse doesn’t mess around. Their Kick Ass blend is exactly what the name implies—a bold, powerful dark roast that makes its presence known.
The flavor profile is earthy and chocolatey with a smoky finish. It’s intense but not burnt. If you want your coffee to wake you up with flavor as much as caffeine, this delivers.
All Kicking Horse coffees are organic and Fair Trade, which is a nice bonus if that matters to you.
Tasting notes: Dark chocolate, earth, smoke
Best for: People who want maximum boldness
Best Budget Option: Café Bustelo Espresso
At $5-6 per 10 oz brick, Café Bustelo is absurdly affordable. And somehow it’s actually good.
This is Cuban-style espresso roast—dark, strong, and meant to be brewed concentrated. The flavor is chocolatey and slightly sweet with a roasty edge. It’s not subtle, but it’s not supposed to be.
Works best in a Moka pot or espresso machine, but drip coffee is fine too. Just know it’s pre-ground, so freshness is a tradeoff for the price.
Tasting notes: Chocolate, molasses, roasted nuts
Best for: Budget-conscious dark roast drinkers
Best Organic: Equal Exchange French Roast
Equal Exchange is a worker-owned co-op that sources beans from small farmer cooperatives. Their French Roast is dark and smoky without being burnt.
The flavor is bold with notes of dark chocolate and a subtle sweetness. The roast is consistent bag to bag, which isn’t always true of smaller organic roasters.
Their whole bean stays fresh longer than most dark roasts I’ve tried. Something about their roasting process seems to preserve the beans better.
Tasting notes: Dark chocolate, smoke, subtle sweetness
Best for: People who prioritize ethical sourcing
Best Single Origin: Counter Culture Forty-Six
Most dark roasts are blends because roasting dark tends to flatten single-origin character. Counter Culture’s Forty-Six proves you can have both.
This blend of East African beans manages to keep some brightness even at a dark roast level. There’s chocolate and caramel, but also a hint of berry that you don’t usually find in dark coffee.
Counter Culture ships within days of roasting. The freshness makes a noticeable difference.
Tasting notes: Chocolate, caramel, berry undertones
Best for: Dark roast lovers who want more complexity
Best Grocery Store Option: Starbucks French Roast
I’ll be honest—Starbucks beans aren’t my first choice. They tend to over-roast. But their French Roast is available everywhere, and it’s decent.
The flavor is smoky and intense with a bitter edge. It’s not subtle. If you like your coffee to taste roasted, this delivers. If you prefer nuance, look elsewhere.
The main advantage is convenience. When you need dark roast beans at 9 PM and only grocery stores are open, Starbucks French Roast will do the job.
Tasting notes: Smoke, char, bitter cocoa
Best for: When you need dark roast right now
Dark Roasts I’d Avoid
Without naming every brand, be cautious of:
- Anything labeled “extra dark” or “Italian” from commodity brands—usually just burnt
- Dark roast that smells like ash when you open the bag
- Pre-ground dark roast that’s been sitting on shelves for months
- Flavored dark roasts (the flavoring masks burnt beans)
How to Brew Dark Roast Well
Use slightly less coffee. Dark roast is more soluble than light roast. Your usual ratio might over-extract. Try reducing by 10%.
Slightly cooler water. 195-200°F instead of 205°F. Dark roast extracts faster and can get bitter with boiling water.
Don’t over-extract. If your coffee is bitter, shorten your brew time or use coarser grounds.
French press works great. The full-bodied nature of French press complements dark roast well.
My Daily Driver
For everyday drinking, I keep Peet’s Major Dickason’s on hand. It’s reliable, reasonably priced, and I never get tired of it.
When I want something special, Kicking Horse Kick Ass or Counter Culture Forty-Six come out. They’re more expensive but worth it for weekend coffee sessions.
The key is finding a dark roast that’s actually been carefully roasted, not just burnt into submission. Once you taste the difference, you can’t go back to char.
This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a small commission if you purchase through these links at no extra cost to you.