Coffee syrups turn good coffee into a customizable experience. Instead of ordering a $6 flavored latte, keep some syrups at home and make exactly what you want.
But not all syrups are equal. Some are cloyingly sweet. Others taste artificial. Here’s what I keep in my coffee bar and what to avoid.
The Major Brands: Torani vs. Monin vs. DaVinci
These three dominate the coffee syrup market. Here’s how they compare:
Torani is the American classic. Sweet, bold flavors designed for American palates. Widely available—you’ll find it at Target, Walmart, and most grocery stores. Good value at $8-10 per 750ml bottle.
Monin is French and tends toward more sophisticated, less sweet flavors. Higher quality ingredients but also higher prices. Better for people who want subtle rather than bold.
DaVinci is the professional’s choice—many coffee shops use it. Falls between Torani and Monin in sweetness. Harder to find retail but available online.
For most home users, Torani offers the best balance of quality, variety, and price.
Essential Flavors to Start With
Vanilla
The most versatile syrup. Vanilla works in almost any coffee drink and doesn’t compete with the coffee flavor. It’s a sweetener that adds depth.
My pick: Torani Pure Vanilla (their non-sugar-free version). Clean vanilla flavor without artificial notes.
Caramel
Second most useful. Caramel adds richness and pairs particularly well with dark roasts. Essential for caramel macchiatos and any drink where you want brown-sugar sweetness.
My pick: Monin Caramel. Deeper, more authentic caramel flavor than Torani’s version.
Hazelnut
Classic for a reason. Nutty sweetness that makes morning coffee feel like a treat. Good in lattes, fine in black coffee.
My pick: Torani Hazelnut. Bold nutty flavor that doesn’t get lost in milk.
Specialty Flavors Worth Having
Brown Sugar Cinnamon
The star of the Starbucks brown sugar oat milk shaken espresso. Warm, spiced, autumnal. Good year-round despite the fall associations.
My pick: Jordan’s Skinny Syrups Brown Sugar Cinnamon for low-calorie; Monin Brown Sugar for full sugar.
Lavender
Floral and unusual. A little goes a long way—too much tastes like perfume. With the right restraint, it’s elegant and interesting.
My pick: Monin Lavender. Other brands tend to taste artificial.
White Chocolate
Sweeter and richer than regular chocolate syrup. Essential for white mochas. Also interesting in iced coffee.
My pick: Torani White Chocolate. Good balance of sweetness and white chocolate flavor.
Pumpkin Spice
Seasonal but worth having in fall. Make your own PSL at home for a fraction of the coffee shop price.
My pick: Torani Pumpkin Spice. Tastes like the real thing.
Flavors to Skip
Sugar-free syrups (mostly): Most sugar-free syrups have an artificial aftertaste. Jordan’s Skinny Syrups are the exception—they taste closest to the real thing. But for most applications, just use less regular syrup.
Fruit flavors: Raspberry, strawberry, peach, etc. rarely work in hot coffee. They’re designed for Italian sodas and smoothies, not lattes.
Overly complex flavors: “Birthday Cake,” “Cotton Candy,” “Marshmallow”—these sound fun but taste artificial and overwhelm the coffee.
Chocolate (from most brands): Chocolate syrup for coffee is different from chocolate syrup for ice cream. Ghirardelli and Monin make good coffee chocolate; most others are too sweet.
How Much Syrup to Use
The standard coffee shop pump delivers about 1/4 oz (7.5ml). Most flavored drinks use 2-4 pumps for a 12 oz drink.
For home use:
- Single shot latte (8 oz): 1-2 tablespoons syrup
- Large latte (16 oz): 2-3 tablespoons syrup
- Black coffee (8 oz): 1 tablespoon or less
Start with less than you think you need. You can always add more. Coffee shops use a lot of syrup—more than most people realize. Home drinks with half the syrup often taste better.
Making Your Own Syrups
Basic syrup is easy: equal parts sugar and water, heated until dissolved. Add flavorings as desired.
Simple vanilla syrup: 1 cup sugar, 1 cup water, 1 vanilla bean (split) or 2 tsp vanilla extract. Simmer until dissolved. Cool and store.
Brown sugar syrup: 1 cup brown sugar, 1 cup water, 1/2 tsp cinnamon. Simmer until dissolved. Cool and store.
Honey syrup: 1 cup honey, 1/2 cup water. Warm until combined (don’t boil—honey doesn’t like heat). Cool and store.
Homemade syrups last 2-4 weeks refrigerated. They’re fresher tasting than store-bought and let you control the sweetness level.
Storage and Shelf Life
Unopened commercial syrups last 2-3 years. Once opened, they’re good for 6-12 months at room temperature. Refrigeration extends life but isn’t necessary for most syrups.
Signs a syrup has gone bad:
- Color has darkened significantly
- Crystallization that won’t dissolve
- Off smell or taste
- Mold (rare but possible in homemade)
Pump bottles are convenient but not essential. A regular pour spout works fine—just wash it occasionally to prevent buildup.
My Coffee Bar Setup
I keep five syrups on hand:
- Vanilla (daily use)
- Caramel (weekly use)
- Brown sugar cinnamon (fall/winter)
- White chocolate (occasional mochas)
- Hazelnut (guest favorite)
That covers 95% of what I want to make. Anything else I buy seasonally or make from scratch when the mood strikes.
Total investment: about $45 for all five bottles. That’s maybe 8-10 coffee shop drinks. The math makes sense.
Best Value: Syrup Variety Packs
If you’re just starting out, grab a variety pack to try different flavors:
Check Torani Variety Pack on Amazon
This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a small commission if you purchase through these links at no extra cost to you.