Organic coffee costs more. Sometimes a lot more. Is it worth paying $18-22 per pound instead of $12-15? Depends what you’re actually getting.
Here’s an honest look at organic coffee—what the certification means, whether it tastes different, and the brands worth buying if you decide to go organic.
What “Organic” Actually Means
USDA Organic certification requires:
- No synthetic pesticides or herbicides
- No synthetic fertilizers
- No GMO seeds (though there are no GMO coffee plants commercially available anyway)
- Crop rotation and soil management practices
- Third-party verification and annual inspections
Farmers pay for certification annually, which is one reason organic coffee costs more. Small farms in developing countries sometimes practice organic farming without certification because they can’t afford the process.
Does Organic Coffee Taste Better?
The honest answer: not necessarily.
Taste is determined by variety, growing conditions, processing, and roasting. Organic practices affect growing conditions, but so do many other factors. Plenty of non-organic coffees taste better than plenty of organic coffees.
What organic certification tells you: the coffee was grown without synthetic chemicals. What it doesn’t tell you: whether the coffee is good.
That said, many specialty roasters who prioritize quality also prioritize sustainable practices. There’s correlation without causation—good organic coffee exists because quality-focused producers often care about organic farming, not because organic farming inherently makes better coffee.
Health and Environmental Considerations
Coffee isn’t typically high in pesticide residues regardless of farming method. The roasting process destroys most residues. If you’re worried about pesticides, coffee is lower risk than many other foods.
The environmental argument is stronger. Organic farming practices are generally better for soil health, water quality, and biodiversity on and around farms. Whether that’s worth a price premium is a personal decision.
Best Organic Coffee Brands
1. Counter Culture Coffee
Most of Counter Culture’s offerings are organic, though they don’t lead with that in marketing—quality comes first. Their Hologram blend is organic and one of the best everyday coffees I’ve tried.
Tasting notes vary by offering, but expect: Complex, well-balanced, fruit and chocolate notes
Price: $15-18 per 12 oz
2. Kicking Horse Coffee
All Kicking Horse coffees are certified organic and Fair Trade. Their Kick Ass dark roast is popular for a reason—bold, earthy, excellent in French press.
Tasting notes: Bold, chocolatey, earthy
Price: $11-14 per 10 oz
3. Equal Exchange
Worker-owned cooperative that sources from small farmer co-ops. All their coffee is organic and Fair Trade. The quality is consistent and the ethics are real.
Tasting notes vary, but their French Roast: Smoky, dark chocolate, bold
Price: $10-14 per 12 oz
4. Allegro Coffee
Whole Foods’ house brand, but better than typical store brands. Many options are organic, and they source thoughtfully. Good mid-range option if you shop at Whole Foods anyway.
Tasting notes vary by roast: Generally clean and well-balanced
Price: $10-15 per 12 oz
5. Dean’s Beans
Small Massachusetts roaster, all organic and Fair Trade. The founder is an activist who’s been in this space since the 80s. Excellent coffee with genuine ethical credentials.
Tasting notes vary: Generally smooth, well-developed roasts
Price: $13-16 per pound
6. Cafe Altura
One of the original organic coffee roasters in the US, dating to 1979. Consistent quality across their range. Good option if you want organic without spending specialty-roaster prices.
Tasting notes: Clean, traditional coffee flavors
Price: $10-13 per 12 oz
7. Lifeboost Coffee
Single-origin Nicaraguan beans, certified organic, shade-grown at high altitude. The company emphasizes low-acid coffee, which some people prefer. Premium pricing but excellent quality.
Tasting notes: Sweet, smooth, low acidity, chocolate notes
Price: $24-30 per 12 oz
Organic Certifications to Know
USDA Organic: The standard US certification. Requires 95% organic ingredients (relevant for blends).
Fair Trade: Not about organic farming but about fair prices for farmers. Often paired with organic certification. Look for Fair Trade USA or Fairtrade International logos.
Rainforest Alliance: Environmental sustainability certification with some pesticide restrictions, but not full organic. Less strict but still meaningful.
Bird Friendly (Smithsonian): Requires both organic certification and shade-grown practices that protect bird habitat. One of the most rigorous certifications.
Should You Buy Organic?
Buy organic if:
- Environmental sustainability matters to you
- You want to support farming practices that prioritize soil health
- You have budget room for premium coffee
Don’t buy organic if:
- You’re primarily concerned about taste (buy by quality instead)
- Budget is tight (non-organic specialty coffee often tastes better than organic commodity coffee at the same price)
- You assume organic means better—it doesn’t, automatically
My Take
I buy organic when the coffee is good, not because it’s organic. Counter Culture and Kicking Horse happen to be organic and happen to make excellent coffee. That’s why I buy them.
I wouldn’t buy mediocre organic coffee over excellent conventional coffee. Quality comes first. Organic is a nice bonus.
This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a small commission if you purchase through these links at no extra cost to you.